Opinion
TIMES EDITORIAL: Steady hand needed on water supply
When two county commissioners showed up at The Cullman Times office Monday to propose a new long-term water plan for the county — taking water from Smith Lake instead of putting a dam on the Duck River — it came as a shock to us.
Imagine how it must have felt for the Cullman Utilities Board earlier that morning.
What these two commissioners, Doug Williams and Wayne Willingham, are proposing is a radical change from what the City of Cullman and the Utilities Board have wanted to do for two decades. The city has taken steps toward building a new reservoir on the Duck River — steps that have cost many thousands of dollars and countless hours of work over the past 20 years — but the two commissioners essentially asked the city to scrap those plans. They think they have a better option.
The commissioners raise some good points. They say building a water treatment plant at the existing Smith Lake would be cheaper than building a new lake and treatment facility to purify the water that’s extracted from it. And, they say, it will improve the quality of water in southern Cullman County.
More importantly — and we think this is what their whole proposal is really about — they want to create a new regional water authority to replace the city’s Utilities Board that has served the area well for decades. They want the county to have a seat at the table.
What they’re requesting is perfectly reasonable. The county is the biggest user, by far, in the local water system, so it makes sense for them to have some control over the decisions that are made about water in Cullman County.
There’s just one problem: The Utilities Board has done such a good job through the years of providing high-quality water at reasonable prices that it’s hard to justify upsetting the apple cart. If the Utilities Board had been generating Hanceville-style headlines with problems and controversies, we could be far more open about shaking things up with a whole new water board. But as things are, we’re skeptical.
Another point to consider: Willingham and Williams are the same commissioners who, as The Times reported this week, gave one county department head a $12,000-a-year raise at a time of slash-and-burn budgets across the board. What kind of message did they send to the other county employees? And more importantly, what kind of message did they send to us about their judgment?
Over the past 20 years, the city has provided a consistent voice of reason on water issues. The county, in contrast, has had upheaval with each election cycle and even outright rebellion over water decisions in the past. Given its track record, we’re skeptical about whether the county government has the steady hand needed to properly manage these vital, long-term decisions.
While the Smith Lake proposal does have some good points, we think the Duck River project would be the wiser alternative for the long range. Besides, we can imagine plenty of court battles facing the Smith Lake proposal. Residents living along the lake don’t take kindly to folks making changes to what goes on with and around the lake.
And the idea of starting a brand-new, built-from-scratch regional board — well — it just doesn’t hold water.
Whichever proposal gets the final nod, it would be a refreshing change to see county and city officials take off the gloves for a change and work together for the good of all county residents.
- Opinion
-
-
TIMES EDITORIAL: City made mistake backing out of mediation plans
If the City of Cullman's Duck River plan really is the slam-dunk case they say it is, the city shouldn't have anything to fear from a mediator.
-
TIMES EDITORIAL: City made mistake backing out of mediation plans
If the City of Cullman's Duck River plan really is the slam-dunk case they say it is, the city shouldn't have anything to fear from a mediator.
-
TIMES EDITORIAL: Steady hand needed on water supply
When two county commissioners showed up at The Cullman Times office Monday to propose a new long-term water plan for the county — taking water from Smith Lake instead of putting a dam on the Duck River — it came as a shock to us.
-
Government doesn’t create jobs
On Friday, the Obama administration released its figures on jobs “saved or created” by the government’s stimulus package. They came up with the number 650,000, but what’s it matter? We’re talking about a completely fictitious calculation.
-
We’re all Americans
My dad was a Democrat and my mom was a Republican. In the past, I have voted as follows: 1960-J.F. Kennedy, 1972-Richard Nixon, 1976-Jimmy Carter, 1980-Ronald Reagan. There were and are different issues facing our nation at different times. Why so much flip flop?
-
We’re responsible for what happens in war
We all know someone who has fought for our country. They come from us. They are our brothers, sisters, fathers, mothers, sons, daughters, and friends. They are fighting right now. They do their job. They do not have a say in where or whom they fight. They follow orders with courage and love of country. They try to get home again.
-
Thanks for a successful event
We thank and appreciate all of the wonderful volunteers and demonstrators who made our 2009 Farm Day a big success.
-
Concerns about water regulations
I would like to recommend to those in charge of the proposed new water system that they adopt strong and enforceable rules and regulations for the protection of the water supply.
-
Fight for freedom
The late Paul Harvey wrote in 1952, “But free men, free to do anything, are also free to do nothing. Apparently that is our choice. We said we no longer wanted “opportunity.” We wanted “security.” And they gave us chains.
-
A broken PACT
State Treasurer Kay Ivey has notified families who purchased Alabama Pre-Paid Affordable College Tuition Contracts (PACT) that the fund is in financial trouble.
-
Obama spreading socialist agenda
A majority elected Obama, the lifelong Socialist. Some didn't know. Some didn't care. Some still don't care but most now know. He has governed from the left, with massive government spending and borrowing, more control of banks, lending and even car companies, a so far failed attempt to cap and trade energy, a so far failed attempt to nationalize health care and a far left Supreme Court appointment.
- More Opinion Headlines
-
TIMES EDITORIAL: City made mistake backing out of mediation plans
