CULLMAN — On Friday, the Obama administration released its figures on jobs “saved or created” by the government’s stimulus package. They came up with the number 650,000, but what’s it matter? We’re talking about a completely fictitious calculation.
That’s because it’s just not possible for the government to create jobs, much less save them.
Now, I realize all the teachers, police officers and firefighters reading this may take issue with my assumptions. After all, they get a paycheck from the government, and someone decided to hire them to do their jobs. But hear me out.
The entire issue, as I see it, comes down to where the government gets its money. The government isn’t in the business of selling widgets, so it has to get its cash from somewhere, and that somewhere is called a tax. It’s taking money from me. It’s taking money from you. It’s taking money from all over the private economy and moving it somewhere else, spending it on something presumably more important than what we would blow it on if it were allowed to stay in our wallets and purses.
And this is where things get interesting.
Just like the government isn’t really creating revenue, just taking cash from one place and moving it to another, the government likewise isn’t really creating jobs. It’s just taking jobs from one place — the private sector — and moving them to the public sector to perform a task that’s more important.
Think about it. If we were allowed to keep all our money, we would spend that money on things that would create more jobs. If we bought things, it would pay for manufacturing jobs. If we bought services, it would pay for people to do those services. If we kept it in the bank, it would create more jobs for investors and bankers and more loans for individuals and businesses. Wherever we put that money, some jobs are going to be created.
The only question is what kind of jobs we create. And that’s where government comes in.
Thank goodness the government has decided to pay for police officers, teachers and firefighters instead of us in the private sector paying for people to clip our toenails and wash our dogs. Thank goodness for the military and the space program, the interstate highways and public universities, because none of those things would exist without government to set them as priorities for our own safety and to advance our own species.
But to say the government created those jobs? I don’t think so. They just took the jobs away from toenail clippers and dog washers, shifting them from less important to more important areas.
It’s defining the importance of those jobs that gets us all riled up, becoming either a Hannity or a Colmes depending on how we see things. Do we want the efficient but brutal free markets to decide? Or do we want the wasteful but equitable public sector to get those jobs?
For me, it all comes down to math. Those 650,000 jobs came from $150 billion in stimulus spending, according to the White House’s numbers. That works out to a whopping $230,000 for just one job “created.”
Sounds to me like the Obama administration shouldn’t be bragging, even if they were capable of creating jobs from nothing but the vapor of Washington’s wisdom.
Derek Price is editor of The Cullman Times. Contact him at editor@cullmantimes.com.
Opinion
Government doesn’t create jobs
- Opinion
-
-
Teamwork leads to great achievements
By Dr. Jan Harris
TEAM – Together Everyone Achieves More. Cullman City Schools is honored to be the only school district in the nation to receive the TEAM AWARD 2011 by the Consortium of School Networking (CoSN), Washington, DC, because of our students’ increased academic achievement due to teamwork. Our mission, in Cullman City Schools (CCS), is to work together as a team to inspire students for lifelong success through character, citizenship and scholarship.
-
PLAYBACK: Will Hoge’s ‘Wreckage’ puts all the pieces together
On his sixth proper studio album, southern rocker Will Hoge is fitting nicely into the groove he has carved out over the previous decade, crawling from bar to bar across the nation playing mostly sold out shows.
-
PLAYBACK:The Beach Boys' Pet Sounds a great summer album
No one could make a more pleasing sound for memorable summers than The Beach Boys.
-
PLAYBACK: The Wallflowers saved the best for last
Known mostly for his famous father, Jakob Dylan built his early career simultaneously riding musical coattails, and trying to escape the thousand-foot shadow cast by his father.
-
Playback: Songs about ... Talking Heads
Talking Heads came to life in the shadowy rubble of New York’s CBGB, where bands such as the Ramones found a welcoming audience.
-
Playback: Blind Boys of Alabama return with reassuring sound, and a few guests
There’s something basic and reassuring about old-time gospel music. That statement is especially true of songs by the Blind Boys of Alabama, winners of six Grammys, including the 2009 Lifetime Achievement Award.
-
Playback: Look past the drama, give Kanye a chance
Can we get much higher?” Before this year’s My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy, the instinctive response to Kanye West’s album-opening question would had to have been “no.”
-
Black Lab keep the 90s alt-rock torch burning
What year is it? 2011? Well, don’t tell California-based rock band Black Lab, because as far as they know, flannel and Doc Marten boots are still in style.
-
Introducing Peace Orchestra
So here's Peace Orchestra. There's no reason why anyone here or anywhere should have heard of Peace Orchestra. There's no snob factor or co-opting of pop esoterica in that statement—Peace Orchestra was never big here, and most people who know and love it found it by accident. One album was all we got, not counting the inevitable various-artists remix homage paid to that one-shot landmark disc. An eponymous cd, the largely instrumental set is a slow, ethereal burn — one laden with too much energy and surface tension to dismiss as mere chill-out music. It rewards casual, volume-down background listening, but that isn't where Peace Orchestra shines. Put on the headphones or, well, turn it up, man.
-
Buying local — ‘the best value’
By Rickey Kreps
The Cullman community is in the solid position that we are today because we charted our future based on what we could do for ourselves. Take for example the foresight to purchase land and develop the industrial parks — not with a handout but with local funds. Responsible budgeting and expenditures prevented our community from taking on long term debts that we could not pay. We’re now hearing from our legislators in both Montgomery and Washington DC that severe belt tightening is on the horizon. We’ll need to figure out ways to do more for ourselves. - More Opinion Headlines
-
Teamwork leads to great achievements
Man Killed in Courthouse Shootout
Video of Ga. Man Who Killed Girl Released
Air Force Airlines: Leaders Get Polished Service
Ga Girl Fights Off Kidnapper at Walmart
Nevada Highway Patrol, City Settle Beating Case
White House Attacks Romney on Birth Control
Homs Bombardment Continues, Global Outcry Grows
Mo. Teen Gets Life Sentence for Killing Girl, 9
Lower-hassle Screening to Be Tested at Airports
Raw Video: Dog Rescued From Icy Colo. Water
Helmet Camera Captures Calif. Fire Rescue
Worker Tells 911: Powell 'exploded the House'
Triple Win: Santorum Takes Minn., Mo., Colo.
Injured Marine Inspired by Homecoming
No Rape Charges Against Son of NYPD Commissioner
Egypt's Ruling Generals Play Risky Game With US
Former Komen Exec Defends Funding Cut
Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix
Calif. Gay Marriage Ban Ruled Unconstitutional
Jury Selection for Ex-UVa Athlete Enters 2nd Day
