CullmanTimes.com - Cullman, Alabama

Editorials

January 15, 2014

Mutilation or punishment?

CULLMAN — Reports of sex offenders preying on children is a troubling issue for society.

Just thinking about an adult taking advantage of a child enrages most caring people. It’s not uncommon for the average person to call for harsh punishment for the offender, and few people disagree.

Nonetheless, Alabama state Rep. Steve Hurst, R-Munford, is treading into dangerous territory with his bill to implement physical castration of offenders whose victims are under 12 years old. According to Hurst, the offender should serve prison time and not be released until undergoing castration.

Several states and countries already use chemical castration as a means to stop convicted sex offenders from repeating their crimes. However, chemical castration is not permanent.

Hurst’s proposal has concerns and flaws that can’t be ignored as the legislative session gets under way.

Punishment for sex offenders is already in place. By enacting a new law, lawmakers would essentially be saying that prison is not a form of punishment for this crime. In addition, forced physical castration contradicts the spirit of the United States.

While it can be argued that a sex offender takes away the rights of his victims, castration would be a form of mutilation endorsed by government. In Alabama, and all over the Deep South, cases have been overturned after long years of presumed guilt involving black citizens. Who is to say that government-ordered castration is not a return to the era when Alabama lawmakers supported sterilization of poor women, most of whom were black. Will the Hurst bill become just another perceived method of discrimination based on race as much as criminal action?

And what will be the compensation for someone who is convicted of a sex offense crime but years later is exonerated? That person will be permanently scarred by the heavy hand of government.

Thinking about the means to reduce and eliminate sex offense crimes is certainly worth exploring at the government level. Nevertheless, proposals that explore or mandate desecration of the body leaves room for errors that cannot be reversed.

Alabama’s reputation from the sterilization programs of the last century remains horrifying. This state should not even consider anything close to the atrocities of the past.

1
Text Only
Editorials
  • EDITORIAL: Gaining a lifetime of success

    The arguments for a deeper investment in the arts for public school children are overwhelmingly favorable. The money is simply not following the logic.

    April 6, 2014

  • EDITORIAL: Gun bill backfires

    State Sen. Scott Beason, a Gardendale Republican, who will soon vacate his seat, is feeling a sense of disappointment that his bill to allow Alabamians to carry loaded handguns in their cars without a concealed weapon permit was shot down this week.

    April 5, 2014

  • EDITORIAL: Above and beyond

    The announcement of the annual Distinguished Citizen and Unsung Heroes recipients by The Cullman Times has revealed another lineup of caring people who go the extra mile in building a better local community.

    April 3, 2014

  • EDITORIAL: A chance to lead growth

    In an era that concluded about a generation ago, residents of any average town or city in America had pretty much one destination for shopping.

    April 2, 2014

  • EDITORIAL: Out of date, out of time

    The Alabama State Constitution, one of the nation’s oldest at 113 years old, continues to linger despite a wide range of efforts to completely rewrite the document.

    April 2, 2014

  • EDITORIAL: A private matter on display

    Following the arguments generated by legalized abortion leave many people in this generation walking away from the issue with a sense of confusion.

    April 1, 2014

  • EDITORIAL: Drug policy sensible, needed

    Cullman City School officials’ decision to slow plans for implementing a student drug testing program was reached after a series of public input meetings.

    April 1, 2014

  • Rage against the weather

    A lot of things can be predicted in life. Economic downturn. A sour reaction to a bill in Congress or the president’s State of the Union address.

    February 3, 2014

  • A legacy protected by truth

    The holiday commemorating the life and times of Martin Luther King Jr. passed with various celebrations and speeches across the nation.

    January 21, 2014

  • Ignoring the state’s needs

    Two points about the Alabama budget process are coming to light, and both are disturbing.
    With the Legislature in session, reports are already showing that lawmakers will have more money to spend on education and less for all the other vital state services that fall under the strained General Fund.

    January 20, 2014